Ikona z Manoppello: czy istnieje nauka alternatywna?

Mirosław Piotr Kruk

Abstract

Images with a special status of not being human-hand-made, or acheiropoietic works, arouse special interest and, sometimes, emotions. Recently, the status of the image stored in the Capuchin monastery in Manoppello has been discussed. According to several authors, it is a true, authentic image of Christ, which could be confirmed by the extraordinary properties of the painting on the fabric. This review concerns one of the studies that pretends to be scientific, but concludes with the necessity to assume that there is no way to explain the circumstances of this image’s creation but supernatural. The most disturbing fact is that the authors postulate that supernatural circumstances should be considered equal to the prevailing primacy of the need for theses verification. It was pointed out that such a postulate leads to abuse and, above all, does not stand up to criticism in the light of historical and physico-chemical researches that have been carried out in recent years. Instead of taking them into account and seeking solutions to questionable issues through a critical analysis, the authors preferred to say that the object represents a supernatural phenomenon. However, it is difficult to accept their statement, especially as their research and publication were financed with scientific grants.
Author Mirosław Piotr Kruk (FH / IAH)
Mirosław Piotr Kruk,,
- Institute of Art History
Other language title versionsManoppello icon: is there alternative science?
Journal seriesPorta Aurea, ISSN 1234-1533, (C 10 pkt)
Issue year2017
Vol16
Pages239-248
Publication size in sheets0.5
Languagepl polski
Score (nominal)10
ScoreMinisterial score = 10.0, 24-07-2019, ArticleFromJournal
Citation count*
Cite
Share Share

Get link to the record


* presented citation count is obtained through Internet information analysis and it is close to the number calculated by the Publish or Perish system.
Back