Niespójność recenzji a wynik postępowania habilitacyjnego. Próba analizy w dyscyplinie socjologia

Łukasz Remisiewicz


The aim of the paper is to show the scale of preparing habilitation reviews ending with untypical conclusions and the impact of such reviews on the outcome of habilitation proceedings in one discipline – sociology. The general analysis of the outcome of the review comes down to the final conclusion; the detailed analysis proposed by the author also takes into account the degree of strengthening or weakening of this conclusion. In particular, the weakening of a positive conclusion may indicate that the actual evaluation of the work is rather negative and differs from the nominal evaluation. The article begins with a theoretical introduction in which the author analyzes the legal aspects of reviewing the achievements to the habilitation degree, the imperfections of this process indicated in the literature, and briefly refers to American and Polish research in the field of pragmatics of RPT reviews, which provide tools to interpret the mechanism of formulating unobvious conclusions. A study conducted on a sample of 130 habilitation cases in sociology from 2012–2019 showed that the results of the proceedings were rather consistent with the results of the reviews. Nevertheless, a set of “border proceedings” have been identified that have received reviews with a low degree of certainty (weakened) or some, but divergent, degree of certainty. In their case, the outcome of the proceedings was unpredictable, i.e. proceedings with the same review configuration ended in different ways.
Author Łukasz Remisiewicz (FSS/IPSJ)
Łukasz Remisiewicz,,
- Institute of Philosophy, Sociology and Journalism
Other language title versionsDetailed conclusions of the reviews and the result of the habilitation proceedings. The attempt to analyze the field of sociology
Journal seriesNauka, ISSN 1231-8515, e-ISSN , (N/A 20 pkt)
Issue year2019
Publication size in sheets0.90
Keywords in English promotion reviews, habilitation reviews, assessment, consistency, university, higher education
Languagepl polski
LicenseRepository; published final; Other open licence; with publication
Remisiewicz_Lukasz_Niespojnosc_recenzji_2019.pdf Remisiewicz_Lukasz_Niespojnosc_recenzji_2019.pdf 170,91 KB
Score (nominal)20
Score sourcejournalList
ScoreMinisterial score = 20.0, 28-01-2020, ArticleFromJournal
Citation count*
Additional fields
LicencjaKorzystanie z tego materiału jest możliwe zgodnie z właściwymi przepisami o dozwolonym użytku lub o innych wyjątkach przewidzianych w przepisach prawa, a korzystanie w szerszym zakresie wymaga uzyskania zgody uprawnionego.
Share Share

Get link to the record

* presented citation count is obtained through Internet information analysis and it is close to the number calculated by the Publish or Perish system.
Are you sure?